Junior depot comparison 🥇 The best children's depots & guides

The most important thing from the Junior Depot comparison & guide in advance

With a junior depot you can optimally seed capital for the child build up ✅

direct banks offer better conditions at Junior Depots ✅

With a junior depot you can use additional allowances Save taxes ✅

Due to the preferential tax treatment of the junior depot, this is allowed Money used only for the child become ✅

When choosing a bank for a junior custody account, you should an established broker fall back ✅

With a junior depot your child benefits from the capital growth of securities with the help of the tax authorities. Therefore, with such a children's depot, you offer your child the best possible start into adult life. As soon as you have the financial means to do so, you should think about saving for your child. Due to the lack of interest, it is advisable to think about securities and to open a custody account for the child. You can get suggestions for which children's depot you should choose in this  Junior depot comparison. For this we look at the most well-known providers. That includes that comdirect junior depot, that ING Junior Depot, that Junior depot of the Consorsbank, that u18 Depot of the DKB, that Scalable Capital child account, that Children's depot from Smartbroker and the Depot for minors from Flatex.

The children's depot is a tax-saving model. you should you Pitfalls in health insurance and BAföG consciousness. It is also essential to stock the children's depot with a long-term focus. If you are unsure, this article will help you Depot for children: papers, taxes & pitfalls continue.

Junior depot comparison: The best depots for your child at a glance

Which is the best depot for your child is different for each individual. It depends on how often you want to trade, which ETF providers you prefer, what your savings plans are, and so on. Of the Junior depot comparison provides you with an overview of the best-known providers of underageDepots and their specific Advantages and disadvantages.

 Offererannual costsPros and cons of junior depotinfo
#1: Consor bank


Depotvergleich : sehr gut (18/20)


Consorsbank in a depot comparison »


Logo Consorsbank.
Provider designation: junior depot

custody fee 0 €



ETF savings plans:
0 euros for 270 ETFs
1.5 % off course for about 330 other ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 25 €

Order commission:
3,90 € in the first 12 months
€9.90 + 0.25 % (max, €59.90) after the first 12 months










advantages



Free securities account (also without purchases)
20 euros free for a savings plan lasting at least 12 months
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 270 pieces)
Savings plan starting at 25 euros
large ETF selection: approx. 600 pieces
Inexpensive one-time purchases: from EUR 3.95 per order



Disadvantages



Existing customers pay more for one-time purchases
Order fee for one-time purchases more expensive after 12 months



20 euros bonus

#2: Comdirect


Depotvergleich : sehr gut (17/20)


Comdirect depot comparison »
Logo comdirect
Provider designation: junior depot

custody fee 0 € (only with savings plan or 2 purchases per quarter)



ETF savings plans:
0 euros for 135 ETFs
1.5 % off course for about 500 more ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 25 €

Order commission:
3,90 € in the first 12 months
€9.90 + 0.25 % (max, €59.90) after the first 12 months

advantages



25 euros free for a savings plan lasting at least 1 month Action expired
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 135 pieces)
Savings plan starting at 25 euros
large ETF selection: approx. 600 pieces
Inexpensive one-time purchases: from EUR 3.90 per order



Disadvantages



Existing customers pay more for one-time purchases. After 12 months you are an existing customer.
Depot only free of charge with a savings plan or 2 purchases/quarter

#3: ENG

Depot comparison: good (16/20 points)


ING depot comparison »
Logo ING
Provider designation: Direct Depot Junior

custody fee 0 € (only with savings plan or 2 purchases per quarter)



ETF savings plans:
0 euros for 150 ETFs
1 € for approx. 550 further ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 1 €

Order commission:
2,90 € in the first 6 months
€4.90 + 0.25 % (max, €69.90) after the first 6 months

advantages




Free securities account (also without purchases)
6 months only €2.90 per order
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 145 pieces)
large ETF selection: approx. 715 shares
Inexpensive one-time purchases: from EUR 3.90 per order



Disadvantages



Savings plan only from 50 euros

Existing customers pay more for one-time purchases. After 12 months you are an existing customer.
Order fee for one-time purchases more expensive after 6 months

#4: Flatex

Depot comparison: good (16/20 points)


Flatex in depot comparison »
Logo Flatex
Provider designation: Depot for minors

custody fee 0 € (only if there is no money in the clearing account)



ETF savings plans:
0 Euro + ~ 0.2 % from course (ATC) for 150 ETFs
1.50 Euro+ ~ 0.2 % from course (ATC) for about 750 other ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 50 €

Order commission:
5,90 €+ exchange fee (regardless of order volume)




advantages




Free securities account (also without purchases)
cheap one-time orders for €5.90 permanently possible
large ETF selection: approx. 900 shares


Disadvantages



Savings plan only from 50 euros

Negative interest on clearing account
Additional ATC fees that you have to look for individually for each ETF on the Flatex website

#5: DKB

Depot comparison: medium (14/20 points)


DKB depot comparison »

Logo DKB
Provider designation: u18 depot

custody fee 0 €



ETF savings plans:
0,49 € for 119 ETFs eligible for savings plans
1,50 € for 410 more ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 50 €



Order commission:
10 €+ exchange fee3 up to €10,000
25 €+ exchange fee3 from €10,000.01

advantages


Free securities account (also without purchases)
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 270 pieces)
large ETF selection: approx. 520 shares
Very large savings plans up to €100,000 can be created



Disadvantages


Savings plan only from 50 euros
Order fee for one-off purchases rather expensive

#6: Smart Broker

Depot comparison: very good (17/20 points)


Smartbroker depot comparison »
Logo Smartbroker
Provider designation: Children/Junior depot

custody fee 0 €



ETF savings plans:
0 € for over 270 ETFs eligible for savings plans
cheap 0,20 % (at least EUR 0.80) for 321 other ETFs
Minimum savings rate: 50 €



Order commission:
0 € at gettex;
1 € at Lang & Schwarz;
4 € at all other German stock exchanges (regardless of the order volume)



advantages




Free securities account (also without purchases)
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 270 pieces)
Savings plan starting at 25 euros
large ETF selection: approx. 600 pieces
Free one-time purchases via gettex
cheap 4 € flat fee on all German trading floors



Disadvantages



Web interface not state of the art
waiting list!



Currently there is only one waiting list for the junior depot available at Smarbroker!

#7: Scalable.capital

Depot comparison: good (16/20 points)


Scalable. Capital in a depot comparison »
Logo Scalable.Capital
Provider designation: children account

custody fee 0 €



ETF savings plans:
0 € for any number of Prime ETF (600 available) at the free broker without a monthly fee
0 € for another savings plan (another 700 available) at the Free Broker
0,99 € for each additional savings plan with the Free Broker
0 € at Prime Broker for €2.99/month




Order commission:
0,99 € with the free broker without a monthly fee
0 € at Prime Broker for €2.99/month



advantages




free securities account in the Free-Broker version
Numerous free ETFs available in the savings plan (currently 600 pieces)
Savings plan starting at 25 euros
large ETF selection: approx. 700 shares
Inexpensive one-time purchases for only €0.99 or for a flat rate of €2.99



Disadvantages



Savings plans cannot be made dynamic and can only be set on a monthly basis

Junior depot comparison: The Consorsbank

Opening a junior depot at Consorsbank is very easy. In addition, the depot is for your child for free. If you decide to set up a savings plan for 25 euros or more, Consorsbank will add another 20 euros as a bonus. To do this, you have to save the savings plan in the Consorsbank junior depot for 12 months without interruption.

Consorsbank junior depot: costs

The Consorsbank Junior depot is free of charge. In contrast to other junior depots, there are no further conditions, such as a certain number of minimum trades per quarter (⇾ comdirect). In addition, Consorsbank has a campaign running, with the junior depot giving 20 euros free for a savings plan lasting at least 12 months (as of June 17th, 2020). In addition, one-time purchases in the Consorsbank Junior depot are inexpensive: from EUR 3.95 per order you only have to shell out. Numerous ETFs are available completely free of charge via savings plans (currently 275 pieces).

Consorsbank: Germany's first online broker with many good offers of free ETFs

The Consorsbank was the first online broker in Germany. It therefore has the necessary expertise and also has some good offers.

Almost 600 ETFs that are eligible for a savings plan are available via Consorsbank's junior depot. An excellent value. With this, the Consorsbank almost comes close to the 711 savings plans offered by ING. But even with almost 600 savings plans, there should be something for everyone. Also particularly liked that 14 Vanguard ETFs can be saved in the junior depot of the Consorsbank.

Bei der Consorsbank können  auch die beliebten Vanguard Fonds können bespart werden. Screenshot:Justetf.com
Junior Depot Consorsbank: The popular Vanguard funds can also be saved. Screenshot: Justetf.com

One-off investments can also be made at fair fees with the Consorsbank junior depot. At the beginning, this is around 4 euros for purchases up to 20,000 euros. After a year, the fees for one-time purchases of up to 2,000 euros will increase to around 10 euros.

Opening of a junior depot at Consorsbank

To the Opening of Consorsbank's junior depot you click on the button above and then on trader account open.

Consorsbank Junior Depot für Kind eröffnen: Zur Eröffnung klickst du zunächst auf Trader Konto eröffnen.
Consors Bank Junior Depot: To open a trader account, first click on it.

In the next step you will receive a selection for whom you want to open the trader account. Here you choose you at the bottom point "Do you want to open an account for a minor child?" "Yes" off and then click Continue.

Hier wählst du beim unteren Punkt „Wollen Sie ein Konto für ein minderjähriges Kind eröffnen?“ „Ja“  aus und klickst dann auf Weiter.
Open a Consors Bank Junior custody account for a child: Here you select “Yes” for the lower point “Do you want to open an account for a minor child?” and then click on Next.

The next step takes you to the mask for entering your personal information. This application for Trader account for minors you fill out completely. This requires information about the child and both legal representatives. After you have filled everything, the application will be sent to the bank. Now you have almost opened your junior depot at Consorsbank. The bank will then tell you everything else.

Antrag zum Trader Konto für Minderjährige mit persönlichen Angaben Ausfüllen.
Open a Consors Bank Junior custody account for a child: Fill out the application for a trader account for minors with your personal details.

Junior depot comparison: open a comdirect or Consorsbank depot for a child?

The comdirect depot is only free with a savings plan or 2 purchases/quarter. This means that in terms of flexibility, Consorsbank's junior depot is the nose front Has. It stays free, even if you suspend your offspring's savings plans and don't make any purchases. The Comdirect rewards the opening of a junior depot with a subsidy of 25 euros, which Consorsbank does as well. So there is a tie here.

Savings plans can be purchased from the comdirect junior depot 25 euros be completed. The savings rates can be monthly, every 2 months or quarterly. Also can single payments such as the investment of birthday bonuses or Christmas bonuses in the comdirect junior depot.

That However, Consorsbank Kinderdepot offers more ETFs compared to the comdirect Junior-Depot as savings plans. In addition, the Consorsbank custody account for minors scores with a reduced order fee for the first 12 months. While you pay 10 euros for a smaller order with the comdirect junior depot, it is only 4 euros in the Consorsbank junior depot. With the Consorsbank children's depot, you save 6 euros on one-off investments within the first 12 months...

My recommendation: open a junior depot for children at the consor bank

The Consorsbank is a reputable partner that has been active in the market for a long time. The selection of ETFs is very large at Consorsbank. In addition, the popular Vanguard ETF can be saved with the Consors Bank Junior Depot. Also the Vanguard ETF Vanguard FTSE All World UCITS ETF with the WKN A1JX52 can be bought or saved in the Consors Bank Junior Depot. The depot remains free if it is not actively used for a period of time. Last but not least, the Consorsbank scores with a bonus of over 20 euros, while there is no one-time payment at ING.

You are interested in investing with a Lombard loan. in the Securities loan comparison you can find the best providers in comparison

Opening of a junior depot at comdirect

The opening of comdirect junior depots is very simple and is described in detail on the provider's website. Therefore, the process is only briefly described here. First, the junior depot Application form* completed and signed by both parents. It is then sent to the Comdirect by post.

Open Comdirect Junior depot for children: mask for opening a depot
Open Comdirect Junior depot for children: mask for opening a depot

If the parents are not yet comdirect customers, take your ID to the nearest post office and have the postal employee verify your identity.

The application form contains the usual questions about opening a securities account and can be completed in just a few minutes.

Consorsbank: Open a custody account for a child?

Consorsbank is my recommendation if you want to open a custody account for your child. After all, the bank is a reputable partner that has been active in the market for a long time. The selection of ETFs is very large at Consorsbank. In addition, the popular Vanguard ETF with the Consors Bank Junior Depot be spared. Also the Vanguard ETF Vanguard FTSE All World UCITS ETF with the WKN A1JX52 can be bought or saved in the Consors Bank Junior Depot. The depot remains free if it is not actively used for a period of time. Last but not least, the Consorsbank scores with a bonus of over 20 euros, while there is no one-time payment at ING.

Junior depot comparison: is ING better than Consorsbank?

ING also offers a Junior Depot with attractive conditions. As with Consorsbank, the ING Junior Depot is free even without a savings plan. In addition, one-time purchases can be made for only 2.90 euros in the first 6 months after opening. At Consorsbank it is 1 euro more, but the Consorsbank junior depot offers 12 months reduced fees. Not just six like the ING. From my point of view, a point for the Consorsbank Junior depot. As an established online bank, ING also has numerous ETFS that are eligible for savings plans. More specifically, 673 ETFs are available through a savings plan at ING. After all, 170 ETFs can be saved free of charge. The Consorsbank offers a little more choice here with 275 free ETFs that are eligible for savings plans and therefore collects the next point in the comparison.

ING Junior Depot: Over 170 promotional savings plans available. Screenshot: Justetf
ING Junior Depot: Over 170 promotional savings plans available. Screenshot: Justetf

Also the Vanguard FTSE All World UCITS ETF Distributing can be saved via ING along with five other Vanguard ETFs. Using the Vanguard ETFs as a basis for comparison may seem somewhat arbitrary, but I simply think they're the best out there. So here goes again Point to the Consorsbank. It offers 14 Vanguard ETFs.

Like the Consorsbank Depot, the ING Depot is also free of charge without a savings plan or regular purchases. For the free depot management there is therefore a point for both. As a special treat, the Consorsbank offers a bonus of 20 euros for a savings plan that runs over 12 months. There's nothing comparable at ING.

Consorsbank Junior Depot is better than ING Direkt-Depot Junior

Overall, it is now 5:1 for Consorsbank's junior depot. Discounted trading is possible at Consorsbank for 12 instead of 6 months, the ETF selection is larger and there are more Vanguard ETFs available. Both depots remain free even if they are not actively used for a period of time. The Consorsbank scores with a premium of 20 euros, while there is no one-time payment at ING.

Opening of ING Junior depot (direct depot junior)

You can get the application form for the ING Junior Depot on the bank's website. Enter your child's number here and sign the form together with your partner. You then send the form together with a copy of the child's birth certificate to ING. If you and your partner are not yet ING customers, you will receive a Post Ident Coupon below. You can use this to have your identity confirmed at the post office.

Opening an ING Junior custody account for a child: the ING questionnaire
Opening an ING Junior custody account for a child: the ING questionnaire

My recommendation: open a junior depot for children at the consor bank*

The Consorsbank is a reputable partner that has been active in the market for a long time. The selection of ETFs is very large at Consorsbank. In addition, the popular Vanguard ETF can be saved with the Consors Bank Junior Depot. Also the Vanguard ETF Vanguard FTSE All World UCITS ETF with the WKN A1JX52 can be bought or saved in the Consors Bank Junior Depot. The depot remains free if it is not actively used for a period of time. Last but not least, the Consorsbank scores with a bonus of over 20 euros, while there is no one-time payment at ING.

Which criteria I consider important in the junior depot comparison

The best children's depot is of course only as good as its manager. Consistent saving even in times of crisis and not panic selling are things that are essential for a long-term investment.

However, each legal guardian may have different priorities when it comes to investing money for children. I consider the following criteria to be helpful when selecting a provider.

  • Free depot management: The Comdirect is not an option here, since the Comdirect child depot charges fees if the savings plan is paused for a long time.
  • Free ETF savings plans: The more free ETF savings plans, the better. Fees for non-free savings plans should also be low, since providers can change their free action ETF from time to time.
  • Your desired ETF should be available at the bank. You can find out which ETFs are available from which broker at justetf.com check. Consorsbank offers most of the Vanguard ETFs. Since I consider these to be optimal for most investors due to their cooperative structure, long history and continuous cost reductions in the past, I have made the number of available Vanguard ETFs the ranking criterion in the junior depot comparison.
  • Choose broadly diversified index funds (ETFs) for stocking the portfolio. ETFs on the MSCI World or FTSE World are well suited.
  • Opinions differ when it comes to accumulating (Acc.) or distributing (Dist.) ETFs. Both have been treated equally for tax purposes since 2018. With accumulating ETFs, it's easier from compound interest effect to benefit, since one cannot forget the reinvestment. The emotionally uplifting feeling of receiving dividends in the account speaks for distributing ETFs.

last but not least: The decision for a depot is nothing that cannot be changed again. At least he is Changing a depot in Germany is free of charge by law. So if your provider should increase the fees, you simply switch. With a bit of luck, there's even a decent one exchange bonus from the new provider.

Conclusion on the Junior Depot comparison

In this junior depot comparison, I have limited myself to the best-known providers. What they all have in common is that they have been on the market for a long time. The Consorsbank offer is recommended. With the Consorsbank Junior Depot you can save over 275 ETFs free of charge with a savings plan. In addition, the bank offers the popular Vanguard ETFs and that Consorsbank Junior Depot remains free with a paused savings plan.

If you want to use the Junior Depot to save taxes, you should use the Pitfalls in health insurance and BAföG consciousness. It is also essential to stock the children's depot with a long-term focus. If you are unsure, this article will help you Depot for children: papers, taxes & pitfalls continue.

*Affiliate link: If you get to a provider via one of these links from my website and open an account there, I may receive a commission. This does not result in any additional costs for you. ❤️ THANK YOU for using these links! ❤️

Disclaimer: This is well researched but non-binding information. Under no circumstances are these purchase recommendations! Past performance does not guarantee future results. Securities may fall in price. This is not tax advice. Please clarify tax issues individually with a tax advisor!

summary
Junior depot comparison: comdirect, ING, Consorsbank
article
Junior depot comparison: comdirect, ING, Consorsbank
short description
With a junior custody account, your child benefits from the asset growth of securities with the help of the tax authorities. Therefore, with such a children's depot, you offer your child the best possible start into adult life. As soon as you have the financial means to do so, you should think about saving for your child. For this you need an efficient and cheap depot. Therefore, we look at the most well-known providers. These include the comdirect junior depot, the ING junior depot and the Consorsbank junior depot. In the end, Consorsbank's junior depot emerged as the winner of the comparison!
Author
editor
Konto-Kredit-Vergleich.de
Logo Konto-Kredit-Vergleich.de

3 thoughts on “Junior Depot Vergleich 🥇 Die besten Kinderdepots & Ratgeber”

Leave a Comment

en_US